In a crowded market of single-focus themes, Fame enters as a versatile contender, offering a single, robust toolkit that can be staged in remarkably different ways. Our testing explored its four personalities: a cinematic fashion editorial, an app-inspired boutique, a high-energy fitness store, and a polished jewelry showroom.
Pros.
〰️
Pros. 〰️
✚ Quick-view that actually helps shoppers
When enabled, the quick-view modal includes variant selection, a quantity stepper and direct add-to-cart. Shoppers can evaluate options and commit without abandoning the grid, reducing pogo-sticking and preserving browsing momentum. It’s a small interaction that meaningfully shortens the path to checkout on focused catalogues.
✚ Real-time cart drawer updates from quick-add
Adding from quick-view updates the slide-out cart without a full page reload, keeping the shopper anchored in context. That responsiveness invites a few extra exploratory adds and makes tweaking quantities feel low-effort compared with older patterns that bounce users between pages.
✚ Conversion modules you don’t need apps for
Countdowns, before-and-after sliders, promo pop-ups, newsletter capture and testimonial sliders are available as first-party sections. The toolkit covers urgency and social proof out of the box, letting lean teams stage launches and campaigns without app sprawl. Over-enabling too many capture moments at once can make the page feel busy, so sequencing pays off.
✚ Storytelling blocks that make education feel native
Across presets, manifesto-style panels, alternating image-text blocks and blog surfaces slot naturally into the shopping flow. The effect is a storefront that teaches while it sells, ideal for brands with an origin story or usage guidance.
✚ Mega-menu keeps large catalogues legible
A structured, multi-column header supports deeper category trees and optional imagery. For stores with breadth, that clarity lowers wayfinding friction and surfaces campaigns without turning the top nav into a wall of links.
Cons.
〰️
Cons. 〰️
− Visual polish varies at the edges
Hover treatments aren’t always leveraged for alternate imagery, and certain banner crops can clip important details on mobile. When you’re selling texture and fit, those missing or trimmed angles cost speed in shortlisting.
− Media-heavy modals can hesitate
Variant pickers inside modals occasionally pause when fetching external media. It’s not universal, but the stutter is noticeable in image-dense SKUs and breaks the otherwise smooth rhythm.
− Empty states and recovery paths need love
404s and empty carts are styled but often miss an obvious “Back to shop” cue. Without a recovery action, the shopper experience goes soft right when you should be guiding them home.
− A utilitarian cart drawer aesthetic
The cart drawer does its job but can feel plain compared to the homepage polish, and the animation timing can read abrupt. In dense states, primary CTAs can also skew low-contrast, which invites mis-taps on mobile.
− Wishlist and clarity extras are absent
There’s no native wishlist and sale listings don’t call out remaining stock. Both are helpful for intent capture and urgency signaling, so you’ll likely lean on apps or custom work to close those gaps.
-
The Default preset frames jewellery and small lifestyle assortments with a warm beige-and-gold palette that flatters metal finishes and natural textures. Its home page composes a headline-forward hero followed by a clean categories grid that gently ushers shoppers into curated collections.
What works in this preset
A serif-led hero (“Purely Hand-Crafted Charm for Your Everyday”) lands with quiet authority, then hands off to a four-tile category grid that names Sale, Jewellery, Bags & Belts, and Ceramics—an arrangement that suits boutiques with a handful of marquee pillars. The sequencing reads like a shop window: statement, curation, then story. It’s a simple but well-paced editorial arc for jewellery-first brands.
Where it stumbles
Because the design leans on warm neutrals and soft light, product photos that depart from this mood (e.g., high-contrast studio shots) can jar against the palette. Merchants mixing disparate photography styles may need to re-grade assets to maintain the preset’s calm, premium feel.
-
Porcelain serves homewares and ceramics with crisp whites, taupe accents and a gallery-like calm. It privileges negative space and still-life photography so textures and silhouettes stay centre-stage.
What works in this preset
A serene hero of vessels and simple copy establishes an exhibition tone before yielding to a two-column mosaic that mixes lifestyle and product tiles. The result is editorial without being fussy—ideal for ceramics where glaze, proportion and light matter. The mosaic invites lingering and works as a quiet brand introduction.
Where it stumbles
Out of the box, the home design underplays overt promotional call-outs. Brands that rely on visible urgency elements will likely spend time inserting those sections to match more commercially forward presets. The aesthetic priority is clear; you’ll tune the balance if launches and offers drive your calendar.
-
Aroma brings a warm terracotta palette and an editorial, magazine-like energy to décor and modern craft stories. It plays with diagonal breaks and irregular grids to add movement and a slightly tactile, scrapbook feel.
What works in this preset
Rotated collage sections puncture the standard grid and thread lifestyle with product shots, creating a rhythm that feels handcrafted and contemporary. For brands built on ambience—scents, textiles, tableware—the diagonals help communicate mood beyond a straight catalogue. The effect is distinctive without tipping into gimmickry when content is curated.
The featured-products mosaic uses varied tile sizes to stage hero SKUs against supporting pieces. That staggered emphasis can guide shoppers toward the intended lead while still surfacing depth in the range, especially when assortment breadth is modest.
Where it stumbles
The same diagonal and mosaic play that energises the page can overwhelm when every tile competes for attention. If you push too many items into these sections, the eye loses the intended hierarchy and scanning slows. This preset rewards restraint in number of tiles and careful image selection.
-
Outline targets fashion, using muted neutrals and oversized imagery to showcase drape, texture and fit. A full-bleed hero video sets a runway-adjacent tone before handing off to clean, legible product grids.
What works in this preset
A full-screen hero video with headline overlay adds motion without stealing focus from garments; it reads as brand film rather than background noise. For clothing, that extra dimensionality helps shoppers imagine movement and fabric behaviour before drilling into a PDP. The transition into collection content feels smooth and intentional.
Where it stumbles
On some scrolls the large hero can leave a faint “hairline” gap between sections, a minor visual seam that breaks the otherwise seamless flow. It’s not disruptive, but it slightly reduces the luxe feel the preset otherwise achieves.
-
Habits is tuned for skincare and wellness, mixing olive and sage tones with calm, instructional storytelling. The layout interleaves teaching moments with shopping blocks to build trust alongside desire.
What works in this preset
A lifestyle-plus-product hero sets a routine-oriented mood for the scroll and brings the category’s ritual focus into the first screen. Paired with the preset’s earthy palette and clean typography, the opening composition reads reassuring and instructional without losing polish.
Niche Suitability
Not Ideal For
-
Artisan brands and small-to-medium catalogues that want an elegant editorial frame with built-in conversion scaffolding. Handmade’s presets deliver distinct moods—jewellery atelier, gallery ceramics, warm décor, fashion lookbook, wellness educator—while keeping a cohesive, premium feel.
-
Stores that measure success by rapid, uniform quick-add from dense grids may prefer a pattern built expressly for speed shopping. If your KPI is fastest possible list-to-cart cadence with minimal interaction, a more utilitarian catalogue-first layout could be a better fit.
-
The theme supplies many sections and conversion patterns, but teams will spend time tuning composition per preset and sequencing conversion modules to keep pages focused. Expect an initial round of content curation and interaction QA before go-live.
Final Recommendation
★ 8.0/10
Rating
-
Broad first-party modules (quick-view, countdowns, before-and-after sliders, pop-ups) reduce reliance on apps.
8
-
Setup is straightforward, but merchants should balance storytelling sections to avoid clutter.
7
-
Touch-friendly sliders and a steady header keep navigation and interaction fluid on phones.
9
-
Pages remain snappy despite rich media.
8
-
Five distinct presets map cleanly to common niches; some editorial layouts (e.g., collages) won’t flatter every product style.
8
FAQ
〰️
FAQ 〰️
-
👑 Yes. Handmade’s presets are tuned to those niches with appropriate palettes, typography and content blocks.
-
Colours, fonts, section order and imagery are adjustable in the theme editor; each preset keeps a distinct look while sharing core structure.
-
Overall performance is solid and animations are smooth.
-
Yes—variant selection and quantity control are available before adding to cart when quick-view is in play.
-
Yes. Adds from quick-view update the slide-out cart in place, keeping shoppers anchored on the grid.
-
Yes. A structured multi-column header with optional imagery keeps deeper category trees scannable.
-
Yes—those sections are available out of the box alongside promo pop-ups, newsletter capture and testimonial sliders.
-
Yes. Manifesto panels, alternating image–text blocks and blog surfaces make education and storytelling feel native to the shopping flow.
-
They map to clear storylines: jewellery atelier (Default), gallery ceramics (Porcelain), warm décor magazine (Aroma), fashion lookbook with video (Outline), and wellness educator (Habits).
This review is based on hands-on testing of the publicly available “Default,” “Porcelain,” “Aroma,” “Outline,” and “Habits” preset demos of the Handmade Shopify theme as of 25 September 2025. Theme features, preset availability and performance can change with subsequent updates from the theme developer.